top of page
Chloe

Debate on Gift of the Magi

The Gift of the Magi is a notable short story written by O. Henry that illustrates an impoverished couple’s internal and external struggle to give a present during Christmas. Della, the protagonist of the story, has only one dollar and eighty-seven cents to buy a gift for her husband, James, also known as Jim. O. Henry portrays a sentimental story with a moral lesson about the meaning of sacrifice and love. Moreover, his writing style filled with twists and turns captures the reader's attention and keeps them engaged throughout the story. The unpredictable ending of the story, where Della and Jim end up sacrificing something of great personal value to obtain a gift for each other yet end up being rendered useless, poses a debate on whether this sacrifice is worth it.


We clearly have to pay for any misconception or mistakes we make in our lives, and we should make decisions particularly useful and practical, but when the topic shifts to love, the core idea changes. It has long been believed, written, and filmed, that love is the deepest and powerfulest sense of emotion regarded as the cornerstone of human experience. For example, if an individual neglects his personal needs, it could lead to negative consequences like burnout and stress. Conversely, when making decisions based on love, individuals, for instance, Della, prioritize the well-being of their loved ones above their desires. Her precious hair below her knees, her pride, a treasure saved for at least 15 years, is sold to buy a present for her beloved husband. Jim, her husband, on the other hand, sold his cherished pocket watch passed down through generations to buy expensive combs for Della’s hair. However, making this “wrong” decision strengthens their relationship and creates a sense of closeness. This sacrifice exemplifies the true spirit of giving and selflessness, showing that their love for each other is more valuable than any material possession.


Our world is brimming with couples who give each other presents, yet it is hard to find those willing to give up and sacrifice their prized possession. Sadhu Vaswani once said: “True love is selfless. It is prepared to sacrifice.” Both protagonists in The Gift of the Magi, Della, and Jim, gave up their cherished assets for one another. From this attitude and eagerness they put in for the present, although the ending might be unfavorable, the sacrifice is worth what they obtain from the moment of love they find together. The act of lenses and sacrifice displayed by Della and Jim in giving up their prized possessions for each other not only deepens their love but also demonstrates the true essence of their relationship. Despite the challenges they may face as a result of their decision, both protagonists' love for one another ultimately triumphs. Furthermore, in our lives, most of us are beneficiaries of what we contributed to. From a perspective as a wife, if my husband is afraid of the result of his sacrifice, it is evident that one might not be in love with the other as he is hesitant to sacrifice for the other. When giving something with all your heart, it doesn’t matter if the present is expensive or pragmatic, one who receives the gift will perceive the love and effort you put in to make them happy.


I don't debate that practical considerations should be made during decisions, I don’t even debate that sacrificing something of great personal value for gifts that lose their actual utility can be viewed as imprudent. What I fervently dispute is that the gesture of love, giving secret gifts to each other, may be seen as unworthy due to the somewhat “bad” consequence. A gift is viewed as valuable or useful for two reasons: one is its practical use, and the other is its meaningful value. Anything accustomed that can provide a positive impact can also be called worthy. We can tell that the presents given by Della and Jim both have a considerable meaning of love for each other. Therefore, the gifts can be seen as valuable and worthy as one obtains an emotional connection with each other. For instance, Della's and Jim's choices to sell their possessions show their deep love and willingness to give up something for each other, reflecting their selflessness and desire to make one another happy. These acts of love make their gifts even more valuable and worthy, as they symbolize the strength of their relationship and the importance they place on each other’s happiness.


The Gift of the Magi is a timeless tale that captures the core of selfless love and sacrifice. The characters in the story serve as a reminder of the power of love and how it can bring contentment to those involved. Here is the thing—sacrifices and selflessness can turn out to be imprudent and unserviceable, yet gifts usually symbolize connection and bond between one another; it is the effort we put in that matters. We all make regrettable choices, and we all choose what road we want to walk. The decisions made by Della and Jim are all what they put wrenching effort into—and that is what matters. These sacrifices lead to a realization for the characters as they come to understand the value of their relationship is priceless. This story highlights the idea that true happiness comes from the act of relinquishing rather than receiving and that the value of sacrifices that might turn out to be impractical lies in love rather than their material worth.


9 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page