top of page
Kathy

Critical Review The Dead

“The Dead” is the final story in James Joyce's collection of short stories, Dubliners. Set in early 20th century Dublin during a gathering held by the Morkan sisters, the story mainly focuses on Gabriel Conroy, a sensitive and introspective man. As the evening progresses, Gabriel enjoys conversations with various guests, dances with his wife, Gretta, and gives a speech. However, it is the ending of the story that stands out. While lying in bed, Gabriel experiences an epiphany as he contemplates his life and the realization that he and his wife have grown apart. As his wife quietly cries over the memory of a young lover who died long ago, Gabriel understands that the living and the dead are eternally connected. This profound revelation leaves him with a sense of melancholy and questions his own existence. Let us join Gabriel on his reflection on the cycle of life and death and the profound impact that the memories of the deceased can have on the living.


Throughout the story Gabriel experiences three significant shocks that deeply impact his perception of himself and the world around him. These shocks challenge his self-image, change his understanding of love and intimacy, and ultimately force him to confront his own mortality. The first shock when Gabriel gets blamed for being a man by Lily the maid. Gabriel then encounters Miss Ivors, a fellow guest at the Morkan sisters' gathering. Miss Ivors challenges his identity as an ardent Irish nationalist and leaves him feeling self-conscious and unsure of his own convictions. Miss Ivors' remark forces Gabriel to reevaluate his patriotism and raises questions about his place in Irish society. The final shock occurs when Gabriel overhears his wife, Gretta, crying silently in their hotel room. Gabriel realizes that there is a depth of emotion and experience in Gretta's life that he has never truly understood or appreciated. This revelation changes his perception of their intimate connection and shows how limited his understanding of love is. These three shocks make Gabriel question his identity, his understanding of love, and his place in the world. It is important to face your own shortcomings and recognize the fleeting nature of human existence.


Death can have a big impact on people and can change the perspective they view things. Through Gabriel Conroy's gradual realization of his own mortality and the connection between the living and the dead, the story explores the profound impact of death on individual lives. The death of Gretta's former lover makes Gabriel realize that he cannot compete with a dead person because of the respect the dead person carried for goodness because dead people will never make mistakes. The theme of death serves multiple purposes within the broader context of Dubliners. The theme of death also shows how death impacts people in Dublin society. The characters, particularly the elderly ones, are trapped in routines, past regrets, and unfulfilled desires. Death becomes a metaphor for the metaphorical death of aspirations and dreams, emphasizing the stagnant nature of their lives. The death of Gretta’s first love also guilts Gabriel. Death then becomes a source of remorse for reflecting on the choices made, the paths not taken, and the impact one leaves behind. Death allows people to ponder the brevity and significance of life.


Escaping from your own country is not a solution when facing problems. Gabriel reflects on the notion of escaping his own country as he discovers his wife Gretta's past involvement with a young lover who has since passed away. This realization triggers Gabriel's contemplation of his own life and his longing for escape from the confines of Dublin society. Gabriel romanticizes the idea of traveling to distant lands and experiencing different cultures, which symbolizes his yearning to break free from his own country/society. Moreover, his admiration for the song performed by Molly Ivors, "The Lass of Aughrim," which celebrates love and rebellion against societal norms, further emphasizes Gabriel's longing for escape. The annual dance party at the Morkans' house serves as both a celebration and imprisonment within Irish society. The annual dance party in many ways symbolizes escaping the limitations and constraints placed upon individuals in their own homeland. Escaping from your own country is not the solution to longing for freedom and the search for new experiences outside the confines of familiar surroundings.


"The Dead" from James Joyce's Dubliners paints a picture of the complexities and limitations of life in Dublin society. The story underscores the theme of death as a powerful force that shapes our understanding of life, compelling us to reflect on our own mortality and the significance of how we choose to live. Through Gabriel Conroy's self-reflection and his emotional journey at the Morkans' party, we see the internal struggles faced by individuals in Dublin. The story's conclusion, with Gabriel's realization of his own mortality and the deep impact of Gretta's past love, serves as a catalyst for his introspection and recognition of the fleeting nature of life. The story captures the essence of Dublin and its inhabitants. So let us join Gabriel on his little adventure.


2 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page