"The Cask of Amontillado" details the first-person narration of the confession of a murderer who had eluded punishment for taking his "friend's" life. In its vagueness, foreshadowing, and verbal irony, "The Cask of Amontillado" engenders Poe's signature guttural gothic horror.
Through his vague descriptions of events, the narrator presents himself as biased and unreliable. From the beginning, the narrator, Montressor, grieves about the thousands of injuries and insults afflicted him by Fortunato. The final insult offended Montressor to the point of desiring to avenge himself by taking the life of his friend, yet it is never revealed what any of these insults or offenses that Fortunato supposedly committed are. The vagueness of description from the narrative biases leaves the reader in doubt of Montressor's true intentions and righteousness in his convictions. Furthermore, after locking up Fortunato in the dank cellars of the catacombs, he never asks his enemy to explain himself, instead screaming back at his victim like a maniac. The vagueness and absurdity of his actions degrade his reliability and suggest the question of his mental sanity. Even more so, the retelling of the story fifty years later further dismantles his reputation as a narrator.
Montressor's punishment of Fortunato is inherently subjective, personal, and under no jurisdiction from the law; he becomes the law, the judge, the jury, and the executioner. If justified, his story would not be sick and twisted, yet the sheer unreliability of Montressor creates the horror of "Cask of Amontillado;" it is not righteous revenge, it is a murder of an innocent.
From the very beginning, readers are already aware of Fortunato's ultimate tragic death at the hands of Montressor, but during their journey down the catacombs, foreshadowing increases the story's suspense and horror and invokes pity. Introducing Fortunato as a connoisseur of wine, Montressor reveals his strategy to the reader, lulling the man by the promise of alcohol to his death, an inevitable and unpreventable fate. In the niter-filled catacombs, Fortunato starts coughing but claims that he would not die from it; Montressor cryptically agrees because he knows that his "friend"'s death would be from his hands. Furthermore, the two drink wine together in the catacombs, Montressor toasting to the longevity of Fortunato's life while knowing full well that Fortunato would never again emerge from the crypt. The description of the catacombs also foreshadows eventual Fortunato's death in them; Poe describes the walls to be moved, as if purposely to accommodate the victim, and cites the dimensions to be precisely those of a coffin. Next, Montressor's explanation of his coat of arms hints at the fates of him and Fortunato; despite being bit in the heel by Fortunato's insults, Montressor's foot would ultimately crush the serpent. Finally, Montressor's response to Fortunato's question about his membership in the Freemason society foreshadows Fortunato's death; as a literal stonemason, Montressor would build his grave out of stone and mortar.
The relationship between Montressor and Fortunato is marked with irony, only heightening the pity and horror towards Fortunato's death. While his name means "good fortune," Fortunato has none of that, instead succumbing to a slow and painful death for a crime of which he is not even aware. Moreover, his jester costume and the capricious jingling of the bells contrast with Montressor's black silk mask of petty revenge. The carefree and innocent jester is fooled by Montressor's masked motives, chilling the festive carnival atmosphere through his murder. Montressor's attitude towards Fortunato is self-conflicting; on the one hand, he states that Fortunato is a respected and feared man but is a quack at the same time. Furthermore, though he confesses his loathing of Fortunato, Montressor calls him a friend at the same time. However, at the end of the story, Fortunato ironically gains the upper hand. Mocked by Montressor's conviction in his self-righteousness, he responds with silence, an adamant refusal to accept defeat even in dire situations. While the snake may be stomped dead, its fangs and venom have wounded Montressor, the stomping foot. Nevertheless, the greatest irony of "Cask of Amontillado" is the story itself. Montressor shares his story of revenge with the reader, yet it is not a scheme of revenge but instead an obsessive, maniacal murder. Through the ironic depictions of the intoxicated and carefree Fortunato with the calculating and heartless Montressor, Poe only builds sympathy for the villain, swaying readers away from the protagonist's viewpoint.
Through the vagueness presented by an unreliable narrator, suspenseful foreshadowing, and poignant verbal imagery, situational and metaphorical irony, Poe creates a dark and twisted Gothic masterpiece. The horror of "Cask of Amontillado" extends out of paper and into reality through the repercussions of inherently subjective revenge. There is no standard justifying those who choose to pursue revenge; like Montressor's actions, real-life notions of vengeance are, too, profoundly personal and horrible.
Comentarios